Skip to content
About Log in Sign up Deutsch

Guides · For brands and retailers

Fake clicks, bots, made-up sales: how do I check the figures when creators are paid on results?

If you pay on clicks, views or sales, check every metric against a second source: clicks against sessions in Google Analytics, views against reach and watch time, reported orders against your shop data. The Media Rating Council’s standard separates easily filtered invalid traffic from the hard-to-detect kind, and a gap on its own proves no fraud. Write down your limits in advance, in your own programme or when you set KPIs before launch with wyrld Boost.

By the wyrld team · Last updated: · 9 min read

With wyrld Boost, many creators feature your products at the same time on Instagram, TikTok or YouTube. Your budget is fixed up front, and the creators are paid from it by results.

Key points

  • Google Analytics excludes known bots automatically. Google says you can neither turn this off nor see how much traffic it affected.
  • The Media Rating Council separates general from sophisticated invalid traffic: lists catch the first, the second needs analysis and includes click farms.
  • Assume 1,000 clicks, 620 sessions and 75% consent: the banner accounts for about 207 visits, leaving just 173 for failed loads and bots.
  • Zero errors in 20 random orders only means the error rate is below about 14% with 95% confidence. A 5% limit takes 59 clean orders.
On this page
  1. How easily views, clicks and sales can be faked
  2. What the Media Rating Council standard distinguishes
  3. Ten plausibility checks for creator figures
  4. Worked example: 1,000 clicks, 620 sessions, 4 orders
  5. Sample check: 20 reported orders against your shop data
  6. What should be in writing before the first post
  7. Where the figures come from with wyrld Boost

How easily views, clicks and sales can be faked

MetricExposureTypical manipulationCross-check in your dataLimit to set in advance
ViewsHighBought viewsWatch time, reach, earlier postsMinimum duration per view
ClicksHighBots, link previews, click farmsSessions, time of day, country, deviceWhat counts as a click
Watch timeMediumEndless loops, bought viewsAnalytics export per postWho supplies the export
Sales via linkMediumSelf-purchases, later cancellationsOrder number, address, return statusCut-off after the return period
Sales via codeMediumCode posted on voucher sites, self-purchasesOrder time against post time, a web search for the codeWho may use the code

The further a metric is from the money, the cheaper it is to fake. Bought views cost little; a real order costs the value of the goods, at least to begin with. The ratings in the table are our own assessment based on how the measurement works, not the result of a study.

The platforms ban such methods: YouTube prohibits anything that artificially inflates views, likes or other metrics, and TikTok prohibits trading in services that artificially boost engagement. But a ban is no substitute for a cross-check, because what you pay for is whatever ends up in the report.

What the Media Rating Council standard distinguishes

The US standard from the Media Rating Council (MRC) divides invalid traffic into the kind that is easy to filter and the kind that is hard to detect. General invalid traffic (GIVT) can be found with lists and routine checks: known data centres, bots and crawlers, for example. Sophisticated invalid traffic (SIVT) needs advanced analytics, several points of corroboration or manual work. The MRC includes hijacked devices, click farms run by people and falsified measurement events, up to and including conversions.

The June 2020 paper was written for ad measurement, not for creator links, but the distinction still helps. Google Analytics excludes known bots and crawlers automatically, and Google says you cannot see how much was affected. Anything not on a list can remain in your sessions. For the second group, then, your own cross-checks are all you have.

Ten plausibility checks for creator figures

ComparisonWarning signCheckData source
Clicks to sessionsFar fewer sessions per click than for other creatorsSet the ratio per creator side by sideLink tool, analytics
Sessions to basketsMany sessions, hardly any basketsCompare the add_to_cart event per creatorAnalytics, shop
Visits by time of daySpikes with no post, an even flow overnightPlot clicks per hour against the post timeLink tool export
Visits by countryLots of visits from countries with no audience or no shippingCountry report against the creator’s audienceAnalytics, creator statistics
Visits by deviceAlmost all desktop, though the post runs in a mobile appCheck the device report per creatorAnalytics
Views to followersA jump far above earlier postsCompare the same person’s last ten postsCreator statistics
Views to watch timeMany views, very short playbackAsk for the average view durationCreator statistics
Self-purchasesSame delivery address as the creatorMatch in-house against the creator’s address, clear data protection firstShop system
Codes without clicksCode sales with no post, code on voucher sitesOrder time against post time, search the web for the codeShop system, search engine
Cancellations and returnsRate far above the shop averageStatus per order after the return periodShop system

Creator figures are plausible when they match a second source and the other creators in the same campaign. We have not found a generally accepted percentage threshold for creator links. So use the campaign median as your benchmark and write down beforehand how far from it a creator has to be before you ask, for example half as many sessions per click as the median.

A warning sign is a reason to ask, not proof. A video that travels a long way in another country, or a slow page, can look much like automation in the figures. And don’t compare periods across a change in measurement: since 24 August 2026 YouTube has counted the start of playback as a view, so figures from before and after that date do not measure the same thing.

Worked example: 1,000 clicks, 620 sessions, 4 orders

ItemCountHow to work it out
Clicks in the link tool1,000Export with timestamps
minus bots and automatic previews110Bursts seconds apart, known identifiers
minus failed page loads63What is left of the gap
minus visits without analytics consent207620 divided by 0.75, minus 620
Sessions in Google Analytics620Report by source or UTM
Orders in the shop4Shop system, counted even without consent

A gap of 380 clicks is not proof of fraud on its own, because it splits into several causes and only one of them is automation. All figures here are assumptions. If 75% of visitors consent to analytics, 620 sessions represent about 827 real visits. Google says Analytics sets no cookies of its own without consent; with advanced consent mode it models part of the gap, and the calculation changes.

In the example, what remains stands for pages that never finished loading; in real data it can also hide automation nobody caught. Meta says it introduced landing page views in 2017 because of exactly such failed loads, since slow sites and poor connections make many people give up while they wait. For payment, the definition decides: 1,000 raw clicks, 890 clicks without automation, or 620 sessions. A creator has little say over consent or page speed, which is why the middle figure is often the fairest basis. It just has to be agreed before launch.

Sample check: 20 reported orders against your shop data

The fastest way to check reported orders is a random sample against your shop system, and it is worth doing before any payout that covers many orders. A clean sample is no acquittal, though: no discrepancies in 20 orders only means the error rate is below about 14% with 95% confidence (1 minus 0.05 to the power of 1/20). For a 5% limit you need 59 error-free orders.

What counts as a self-purchase is your call. Amazon’s Associates programme policies prohibit purchases through your own affiliate links, including by friends, relatives or staff. In your own programme the rule can be different; it just has to be set in advance.

  1. Export every reported order with order number, date, amount and creator ID.
  2. Pick 20 orders using random numbers, not the biggest or the most recent. If there are fewer than 20, check them all.
  3. Check in the shop system that the order number exists and that the amount and date match.
  4. Check the status: paid, cancelled or returned.
  5. Check where it came from: was the order placed after the post, and is there a link or code attached to it?
  6. Match the delivery address in-house against the creator’s address. No customer data leaves the company, and because this is personal data, agree the check with your data protection adviser beforehand.
  7. Record discrepancies for each check. If you find one, widen the sample or check every order for that creator.

What should be in writing before the first post

Checking rules only stand up if they exist before the first post; afterwards, any limit looks like an excuse. Six definitions are enough. Our order: these six first, then launch, then the sample check before every payout. What we would not do is suspect a creator because of a single odd figure.

  • Click: raw click, click without automation, or session in the shop.
  • View: start of playback or a minimum duration. Since 24 August 2026 YouTube has counted from the start of playback; TikTok’s ad metrics report 2 and 6 seconds separately.
  • Data source: who supplies which export, with timestamps and in what format.
  • Sale: an order that has been neither cancelled nor returned by the end of the return period.
  • Self-purchase: who is included, for example the creator, their household or their team.
  • Checking threshold: how far from the median a creator has to be before you ask.

Where the figures come from with wyrld Boost

With wyrld Boost you set the KPIs before launch, which is the moment to raise definitions such as click, sale and self-purchase. wyrld tracks clicks through the links, the shops report sales, and creators upload watch time and reach from their own statistics. If people buy in your own shop, you hold the orders anyway. How far reporting goes beyond results per creator depends on the package, so check beforehand what your cross-checks need. It is the wrong route if you need a promise on reach or revenue.

wyrld Boost at a glance

What it is
The campaign service from wyrld, a social commerce platform based in Hamburg, Germany. Many creators feature your products at the same time, so you do not have to book each one. People buy in your own shop, on Amazon or through price comparison: you decide.
Price
You set the budget. Campaigns usually start from €10,000 plus VAT. Creators are paid from the budget according to the KPIs they reach, such as purchases, clicks or watch time. The package price also covers selection, payouts, reporting and a short consultation.
Creators and videos
wyrld selects suitable creators, and each creator decides whether to take part. Creators label campaign videos as advertising. The videos run on the creators’ channels. The right to reuse them yourself is not part of the package.
How it runs
Depending on the campaign, you approve the videos before they go live, or the creators post from your brief. We set out the minimum scope of the campaign in your offer. We do not promise reach or revenue. After the campaign you can see which creator delivered which results.
Who it is for
wyrld Boost is open to brands of every size and in all categories, including brands from abroad that want to sell in Germany, Austria or Switzerland, provided the product and its advertising are lawful. Agencies book as normal customers.
Brand and shop subscription
Separately, this shows you every day which creators feature your products and, where the shop reports purchases, who is selling. Price on request.
FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

How can I spot fake clicks from influencers?

Compare the clicks in the link tool with the sessions in your shop, creator by creator, looking at time of day, country, device and baskets. Spikes with no post and sessions with no action at all stand out. A single value proves nothing; only several deviations together give you reason to ask.

Does Google Analytics filter out bots automatically?

Yes. Google Analytics automatically excludes known bots and crawlers, based on Google’s own research and the Interactive Advertising Bureau’s bot list. You can’t switch this off, and Google doesn’t show how much was excluded. Unknown bots and fake clicks generated by people can stay in the data.

Why does my shop show fewer sessions than the link tool shows clicks?

Usually several causes combine: bots and automatic previews, pages that never finish loading, and people who decline analytics. Only breaking the gap down shows how much of it is automation. A gap on its own is no proof of fraud.

How many orders should I check in a sample?

Twenty orders drawn at random are a practical start. If all of them are clean, the error rate is below about 14% with 95% confidence. For a 5% limit you need 59 clean orders. If there are only a handful of orders in total, check every one.

Is buying through your own link fraud?

That depends first on your own rule. Amazon prohibits such purchases for its affiliates; in your own programme you decide and put it in writing beforehand. No metric can tell you if something is fraud in the legal sense, so if in doubt, take legal advice.

All questions on one page →

Last updated:

Sources

Related questions.

Sell through creators.