Skip to content
About Log in Sign up Deutsch

Guides · For brands and retailers

Our first influencer campaign brought in hardly any revenue: how do I make the case for a second attempt?

Make the case with a post-mortem, not with hope: the symptom in the report, its likeliest cause, the evidence and one specific change. Then put the lessons learned, a smaller budget cap and a stop rule to the managing director. Before that, check if the sales were missing or just the measurement. Possible routes are new one-off bookings, an affiliate programme or wyrld Boost, where budget and KPIs are fixed up front and you choose the shops.

By the wyrld team · Last updated: · 8 min read

With wyrld Boost, many creators feature your products at the same time on Instagram, TikTok or YouTube. Your budget is fixed up front, and the creators are paid from it by results.

Key points

  • If some UTM parameters are missing, Google Analytics help says reports show (not set). That means the attribution is missing, not necessarily the sales.
  • Judge the campaign only after the withdrawal period: in Germany, 14 days from receipt of the goods (§§ 355, 356 BGB). Until then, consumer revenue is not secure.
  • A second attempt changes two levers from the post-mortem at most. The more you change at once, the less you can say what worked.
  • If the post-mortem points to flat fees, the wrong products or missing attribution, wyrld Boost is one route: budget and KPIs fixed up front, you choose the shops.
On this page
  1. First find out: were the sales missing, or only the measurement?
  2. Post-mortem: six symptoms from the campaign report
  3. What a second attempt has to change
  4. When not to propose a second attempt
  5. Where wyrld Boost helps with a second attempt, and where it doesn’t
  6. Message to the managing director: a template to copy

First find out: were the sales missing, or only the measurement?

Three questions tell a failed campaign from a badly measured one, and you answer them before you talk to anyone. An empty report and a weak report look the same, but they lead to very different decisions.

  1. Were the links fully tagged? Google Analytics help says (not set) values appear in reports when UTM parameters are missing, and that if you set one parameter you should set all the relevant ones. Spelling matters too: “Meta” and “meta” count as two different values. If your report says (not set), what is missing is the attribution, not necessarily the sale.
  2. Did you wait long enough? Google Analytics only credits key events, the actions you mark as important (a purchase, say), to touchpoints within the lookback window. So check which window is set: at 30 days, only touchpoints from those 30 days count; for most key events the default, according to the help page, is 90 days. With online purchases by consumers in Germany, an order is also only final once the 14-day withdrawal period has run out, which for goods starts on receipt (§ 355(2), § 356(2) BGB).
  3. Did people buy elsewhere? Anyone who sees a product in a video and later buys it on Amazon or in a bricks-and-mortar shop won’t appear in your shop’s report. So compare the product’s sales across all channels during the campaign with the weeks before.
  • If that turns up some of the revenue, correct the report before you propose a second attempt.
  • If little is left, the campaign was weak. Say so plainly: a post-mortem that explains the failure away will cost you the second attempt.

Post-mortem: six symptoms from the campaign report

Symptom in the reportLikeliest causeEvidence to check firstChange for the second attempt
Lots of views, few clicksVideo with no clear path to purchaseClicks per post, link in story, bio or descriptionPath to purchase in the brief, formats with a link
Clicks but no purchasesProduct page, price or availabilityConversion rate against other channels, stock during the periodFix the page and stock first, then launch
Codes with no attributionOne code for everyone, passed on to othersRedemptions per code against order numbersA separate link and code for each creator
Flat fee onlyYou paid for the post, not the saleContract: what was owed, and was there a sales target?Tie part of the budget to KPIs
Wrong productsNew launch rather than a bestseller, product doesn’t suit the creatorSales rank in the shop, margin, stockBestsellers with enough stock, fewer products
Nothing measuredNo tagging or patchy tagging, only reach in the report(not set) or no campaign in Analytics, missing order numbersA UTM standard and report template before launch

The table runs from the symptom in the report to the change, and you fill it in before you ask for the meeting. If several symptoms apply, the earliest break in the chain counts: with no clicks, the conversion rate tells you nothing. The detailed search, metric by metric, is on our page about views without sales, and matching links, codes and UTMs is covered on the page about measuring revenue.

Write down what you cannot prove, too. A line such as “we don’t know if price was the problem” makes the post-mortem more credible than an explanation with no gaps.

What a second attempt has to change

A second attempt changes two things at most: the ones the post-mortem has evidence for. Change everything at once and nobody can tell what worked. New creators, a new product and new pay all at once is simply a new first attempt. Our order would be: settle the measurement question, write the post-mortem, work out the cap, and only then talk about creators and routes. Start by asking which creators it should be this time and you end up with that new first attempt.

Three things are settled before any money goes out. The cap is smaller: if the first campaign cost €25,000, then €12,000 is an honest second step (example figures). Measurement is in place before the first post, not after it. And the pass and stop thresholds are written down in the test agreement that marketing, finance and the managing director sign.

Three lines to leave out: “It was brand building”, if nobody set a brand goal beforehand. “The algorithm didn’t play along”, because that justifies no change. “We just need more reach”, when the reach you already had did not sell.

When not to propose a second attempt

Not proposing a second attempt is the right call when the post-mortem finds nothing you can change. Four reasons count against it, and each one spares you a second meeting with the same outcome:

  • The margin doesn’t cover the cost per order, even if things go well.
  • Stock or delivery times are no different from the first time.
  • Nobody can be found to own tagging and reporting before launch.
  • The cause lies in the product itself, and creators can’t fix that.

Where wyrld Boost helps with a second attempt, and where it doesn’t

wyrld Boost addresses three symptoms in the table. Flat fees, because the creators are paid from your fixed budget by the KPIs they reach. Wrong products, because you choose the products and the shops. Missing attribution, because afterwards you see which creator delivered which results.

It is the wrong route if the cause lies in margin, stock or the product itself, or if it must be the same creators as last time: wyrld selects the creators, and taking part is up to each creator. The stop rule stays either way.

Message to the managing director: a template to copy

The message names the missed goal first and the proposal second. Lead with the proposal and it looks as though you are covering up the result. Fill in the figures from the report and attach the post-mortem table.

Review and proposal for a second attempt

Subject: Creator campaign [month]: review and proposal

Hi [name],

The [month] campaign missed its target: €[amount] spent, [number] orders kept after returns, €[amount] per order. The plan allowed no more than €[amount].

What we learned:
1. [Symptom and evidence, one sentence]
2. [Symptom and evidence, one sentence]
What we couldn’t prove: [what remains open].

I’d like to propose a second, smaller attempt:
Cap: €[amount], which is [share]% of the first campaign.
Change: [two points at most].
Measurement: set up before the first post, owned by [name].
Duration: [weeks] plus a run-off period until [date].
Pass: no more than €[amount] per kept order.
Stop: at €[amount] or more per kept order, no further budget for this channel.

I need a yes or no by [date]. The test agreement and the post-mortem are attached.

Kind regards
[name]

wyrld Boost at a glance

What it is
The campaign service from wyrld, a social commerce platform based in Hamburg, Germany. Many creators feature your products at the same time, so you do not have to book each one. People buy in your own shop, on Amazon or through price comparison: you decide.
Price
You set the budget. Campaigns usually start from €10,000 plus VAT. Creators are paid from the budget according to the KPIs they reach, such as purchases, clicks or watch time. The package price also covers selection, payouts, reporting and a short consultation.
Creators and videos
wyrld selects suitable creators, and each creator decides whether to take part. Creators label campaign videos as advertising. The videos run on the creators’ channels. The right to reuse them yourself is not part of the package.
How it runs
Depending on the campaign, you approve the videos before they go live, or the creators post from your brief. We set out the minimum scope of the campaign in your offer. We do not promise reach or revenue. After the campaign you can see which creator delivered which results.
Who it is for
wyrld Boost is open to brands of every size and in all categories, including brands from abroad that want to sell in Germany, Austria or Switzerland, provided the product and its advertising are lawful. Agencies book as normal customers.
Brand and shop subscription
Separately, this shows you every day which creators feature your products and, where the shop reports purchases, who is selling. Price on request.
FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

Why did my influencer campaign bring in no revenue?

Only a post-mortem will tell you. Common causes are a video with no clear path to purchase, a weak product page, the wrong products or missing tagging. Start with the earliest break: were there clicks, were there purchases, or was only the attribution missing? Questions about individual creators come after that.

How do I explain a failed influencer campaign to my boss?

Open with the missed goal and the figures: costs, orders kept after returns, cost per order. Then give two lessons you can evidence and say what remains open. Only then comes the proposal, with a smaller cap and a stop rule. Talk of brand building only helps if that goal was agreed beforehand.

How much budget should a second attempt get?

There is no set figure. The cap should be smaller than the first time but still big enough to test your threshold. Work backwards: your target cost per order times the minimum number of orders. If the budget can’t cover that, the test won’t answer the question.

When has an influencer campaign really failed?

When measurement was in place, the withdrawal period is over and the cost per order kept after returns is still above the threshold you set beforehand. An empty report without tagging is a measurement error, not yet a failure. Without a threshold set in advance, failure is hard to prove.

Can wyrld Boost help with a second attempt?

wyrld Boost is one route among several if the post-mortem points to flat fees, the wrong products or missing attribution. Budget and KPIs are fixed up front, you choose the shops, and afterwards you see which creator delivered which results. It comes with no promise of reach or revenue.

All questions on one page →

Last updated:

Sources

The figures in the example are assumptions. The details on Google Analytics come from its help pages, read on 4 November 2026, and may change. This page explains campaign post-mortems in general terms and is not legal advice. Accessed on :

Related questions.

Sell through creators.