Guides · For brands and retailers
How do I compare Meta, Google and creators on profit rather than reach?
Run every channel through the same calculation: net revenue after returns, minus variable costs and channel costs, gives you channel profit, and alongside it you track cost per new customer. Platform figures alone won’t do, because each platform counts by its own rules. Use your shop data as the base and attribute orders through links, discount codes and a post-purchase question. Per-creator numbers come from your affiliate programme, an app or campaigns such as our own offer wyrld Boost.
By the wyrld team · Last updated: · 8 min read
With wyrld Boost, many creators feature your products at the same time on Instagram, TikTok or YouTube. Your budget is fixed up front, and the creators are paid from it by results.
Key points
- In our invented example Meta leads on orders (200), Google on channel profit (€1,470) and creators on cost per new customer (€15.63).
- ROAS only divides revenue by cost and ignores cost of goods, shipping and returns, so it can’t settle a comparison between channels.
- Links and codes usually give the lower figure and the post-purchase question a second one: in the example, cost per order falls between €6.94 and €12.50.
- Your shop records each order exactly once, so calculate from there. The platforms then only supply the costs.
On this page
- Why platform figures and reach alone won’t give you a channel comparison
- One calculation for every channel, in six steps
- Example with invented numbers: three channels, one month, a different winner on each metric
- Attributing purchases to creators: link, discount code and post-purchase question give you a range
- Template: a channel comparison to copy
- Which tool makes Meta, Google and creators comparable?
- Filling in the creators row: campaign figures in your table
Why platform figures and reach alone won’t give you a channel comparison
| Source | How it counts | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Meta ad account | by Meta’s own method | in the account: which window applies and what is included |
| Google Ads | mostly data-driven according to its help pages, 30 days by default for click conversions | model and window for each conversion action |
| Affiliate programme or app | links and codes, by the programme’s rules | cookie duration, whether link or code takes priority |
| Campaign with wyrld Boost | clicks through the links, purchases reported by the shops | which KPIs you set in advance |
| Shopify reports | selectable model; last non-direct click by default in the channel report | the same model for every comparison |
Every source credits itself with purchases under its own rules. The same purchase can turn up in two reports, and the total across all of them can exceed what your shop actually booked. You also have to add cost of goods and return costs from your own numbers. Reach tells you even less: 100,000 creator views and 100,000 feed impressions are different things, and neither says what was earned.
Meta, Google and creators only become comparable when you calculate from the shop. Your shop records each of its orders exactly once, along with returns and discounts. The platforms then only supply the costs.
One calculation for every channel, in six steps
- Set the period and the base: the same weeks for every channel, revenue net of VAT, figures taken once the return period has ended.
- Export orders from the shop and assign each order number to exactly one channel. Write down your priority rule, for example code before link, link before ad. Anything you can’t attribute goes in a row of its own.
- Work out contribution margin per channel: net revenue after returns minus cost of goods, shipping, payment fees and return costs. Use returns per channel, because orders from creator links may come back at a different rate from orders from search.
- Add up the channel costs: ad budget, commission, fees, samples and their shipping, tools, agency. If you are using revenue after discount, discounts have already come off, so don’t count them again as channel costs.
- Subtract channel costs from contribution margin. What is left is the channel’s profit, before fixed costs.
- Count new customers per channel using one rule for all, and divide channel costs by that number. That is your cost per new customer, or CAC (customer acquisition cost).
Example with invented numbers: three channels, one month, a different winner on each metric
| Item (assumed) | Meta | Creators | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orders | 200 | 150 | 80 |
| Net revenue before returns | €10,000 | €7,500 | €4,400 |
| Channel costs | €3,000 | €1,500 | €1,000 |
| ROAS before returns | 3.33 | 5.00 | 4.40 |
| Net revenue after returns | €8,000 | €6,600 | €3,300 |
| Contribution margin (45% of that) | €3,600 | €2,970 | €1,485 |
| Channel profit | €600 | €1,470 | €485 |
| New customers | 110 | 45 | 64 |
| Cost per new customer | €27.27 | €33.33 | €15.63 |
In the example, the winner depends on the question: Meta on orders, Google on channel profit, creators on cost per new customer. All values are invented and say nothing about what Meta, Google or creators actually achieve or how your channels will perform. The creators column stands for creator marketing in general, not for a wyrld Boost campaign. ROAS (return on ad spend) is revenue divided by costs.
The table shows why one metric is not enough. Google generates the highest channel profit in the example, but only 45 new customers on 150 orders; the remaining orders come from existing customers. Cut on channel profit alone and the creators channel goes first, even though it wins new customers most cheaply. It also has the highest return rate here, 25% against 20% for Meta and 12% for Google. So set cost per new customer against customer lifetime value, the profit a new customer generates over time, and decide what role each channel is there to play.
Our rule: no channel gets cut on a single metric. We would update this table every month from your shop data, with channel profit and cost per new customer side by side, and give each channel its role up front. We would use platform figures only to steer within a channel.
Attributing purchases to creators: link, discount code and post-purchase question give you a range
Attributing purchases to creators is always an estimate, so report a range rather than a single number. Links and codes usually give the lower figure, because they only capture people who clicked or entered the code. The post-purchase question gives a second figure, because it also reaches people who saw a video and ordered directly later on.
Say links or codes attribute 80 of 800 orders in a month to creators, which is 10%. In the post-purchase question, 18% name a creator, which extrapolates to 144 orders. At €1,000 of channel costs, that puts cost per order between €6.94 and €12.50. Both ends are uncertain: not everyone answers, discount codes can end up on coupon sites, and someone who names a creator might have bought anyway. Only a test with a control group shows which sales are truly additional.
Post-purchase question
How did you hear about us? ( ) A creator or influencer, namely: ______ ( ) An ad on Instagram or Facebook ( ) An ad on TikTok ( ) Google search ( ) Friends or family ( ) Other: ______
Template: a channel comparison to copy
You can paste the template straight into Google Sheets or Excel. Columns are separated by tabs and the formulas are already in the rows. Variable costs are cost of goods, shipping, payment and return costs. The cost per new customer column shows an error until new customers are filled in. The “Not attributed” row shows how much remains that you can’t say anything certain about.
Channel comparison for one month
Channel Orders Net revenue before returns Net revenue after returns Variable costs Contribution margin Channel costs Channel profit New customers Cost per new customer Meta =D2-E2 =F2-G2 =G2/I2 Google =D3-E3 =F3-G3 =G3/I3 Creators =D4-E4 =F4-G4 =G4/I4 Not attributed =D5-E5 =F5-G5 =G5/I5
Which tool makes Meta, Google and creators comparable?
Start with a spreadsheet, because the calculation only needs exports from your shop and ad accounts. According to Shopify’s help pages, its Performance by marketing channel report shows sales, orders, ad spend, ROAS, CAC and first-time and returning customers per channel, among other things, with the last 30 days as the default. Spend-based metrics such as ad spend and ROAS are available only for channels that report their costs to Shopify, such as a connected ad platform, and the help page lists no channel profit among this report’s metrics. So check in your account which columns you can add, and otherwise enter cost of goods and return costs yourself.
Dedicated attribution tools can pull the exports together, but the priority rule and the costs per creator are still yours to set. To rate influencers on profit, you need one row per creator with orders and all costs. Those numbers come from your affiliate programme, an affiliate app, the platform your creators work through, or the campaign itself. Before you start, ask whether you will get them per creator.
Filling in the creators row: campaign figures in your table
wyrld Boost helps with the creators row of your table: after the campaign you can see which creator achieved which results, and the whole campaign price goes in the channel costs column. It doesn’t work for a comparison built on shop data alone if people are meant to buy on Amazon or via price comparison, because those sales won’t appear in your export. In that case, have them buy in your own shop. Only your own sums will show whether the campaign paid for itself.
wyrld Boost at a glance
- What it is
- The campaign service from wyrld, a social commerce platform based in Hamburg, Germany. Many creators feature your products at the same time, so you do not have to book each one. People buy in your own shop, on Amazon or through price comparison: you decide.
- Price
- You set the budget. Campaigns usually start from €10,000 plus VAT. Creators are paid from the budget according to the KPIs they reach, such as purchases, clicks or watch time. The package price also covers selection, payouts, reporting and a short consultation.
- Creators and videos
- wyrld selects suitable creators, and each creator decides whether to take part. Creators label campaign videos as advertising. The videos run on the creators’ channels. The right to reuse them yourself is not part of the package.
- How it runs
- Depending on the campaign, you approve the videos before they go live, or the creators post from your brief. We set out the minimum scope of the campaign in your offer. We do not promise reach or revenue. After the campaign you can see which creator delivered which results.
- Who it is for
- wyrld Boost is open to brands of every size and in all categories, including brands from abroad that want to sell in Germany, Austria or Switzerland, provided the product and its advertising are lawful. Agencies book as normal customers.
- Brand and shop subscription
- Separately, this shows you every day which creators feature your products and, where the shop reports purchases, who is selling. Price on request.
Frequently asked questions.
Which tool compares Meta, Google and influencers on profit?
To start with, a spreadsheet with exports from your shop and ad accounts is enough. If you use Shopify, its channel report shows sales, orders and new customers per channel, with spend and ROAS only for channels that report their costs. You add channel profit in your spreadsheet. For creators you need per-person numbers from a programme, app or campaign, such as the results per creator after a wyrld Boost campaign.
What tells you more, ROAS or contribution margin?
Contribution margin after channel costs, which this page calls channel profit. ROAS only divides revenue by costs and misses cost of goods, shipping and returns. A channel can have a higher ROAS and still generate less profit if more orders are returned. ROAS is still useful for quick steering within a channel, but it can’t settle a comparison between channels.
How do I rate an individual creator on profit?
Give each creator a row: orders through link and code after returns, the contribution margin on those orders, minus commission, fees and samples with their shipping. After a wyrld Boost campaign you can see the results per creator. Judge on several posts, not a single one.
How many orders do I need for a meaningful channel comparison?
It depends on how much your numbers fluctuate on their own. Look at weeks when nothing changed: if the gap between two channels falls within that range, it tells you little. With few orders, compare whole months rather than single weeks, and keep the calculation going over several months.
Should I count Google ads on my brand name?
Give them a row of their own. People searching for your brand name usually know you already, often through another channel. If those orders sit in with your other Google ads, you can no longer separate what won new customers from what picked up existing demand. The new-customer share shows you the difference.
Last updated:
Sources
This page is published by wyrld, the provider of wyrld Boost, not by Meta, Google or Shopify. Accessed on :